Aerial view of the north end of Anna Maria Island, a pier and turquoise water
Anna Maria Island and its pier from above

Islands & Beaches · Waterfront

Casey Key in Islands & Beaches

Casey Key is a barrier island off Nokomis and Osprey in Sarasota County, between Siesta Key and the Venice Inlet. Its homes sit along Casey Key Road between the Gulf and the Intracoastal Waterway, reached by the Blackburn Point swing bridge and the Albee Road drawbridge.

At a glance

Casey Key at a glance

Casey Key is a Gulf barrier island in southern Sarasota County with two county beach parks, a boat ramp, and a fishing pier at its Nokomis end.

Median asking price
$4.80M
Lifestyle
Waterfront

The area

Living in Casey Key

Overview of Casey Key

Public beaches
Nokomis Beach Park and North Jetty Park
Park hours
6 a.m. to 10 p.m. (county, 2026)
Boat ramp
Nokomis Beach Park, open 24 hours
Lifeguards
Nokomis Beach Park and North Jetty Park

About Casey Key

  • Nokomis Beach Park has a fishing pier, canoe and kayak launch, and a concession
  • North Jetty Park has a picnic pavilion, grills, and a playground
  • Both parks have restrooms and picnic areas

Casey Key is a barrier island on the Gulf coast of Sarasota County, south of Siesta Key and north of the Venice Inlet. It sits in unincorporated Sarasota County, outside any town, with Osprey and Nokomis on the mainland across the Intracoastal Waterway. The name comes from an 1851 United States Coast Survey chart that named the island for Captain John Charles Casey, whose post was actually on a different key to the south. Casey Key Road carries traffic along the island, with the Gulf of Mexico on the west side and Blackburn Bay and the Intracoastal on the east.

The homes are almost all single-family. Some houses face the Gulf with their own beach, others sit on the bay with private docks, and a few wide lots run from the Gulf to the bay with water on both sides. Homes date from 1947 to new houses under construction now, so older homes sit near newly built ones. A few condos and vacant lots come up for sale as well. Asking prices run from the low $1 millions to more than $12 million.

Two bridges reach the island. The Blackburn Point Bridge, a one-lane steel truss swing bridge from 1926 on the National Register of Historic Places, links the north end to US 41 in Osprey, with Blackburn Point Park and the Casey Key Fish House beside it. The Albee Road Bridge, a two-lane bascule bridge from 1963, links the south end to US 41 near Nokomis. Nokomis Beach, the county's oldest public beach, sits off Albee Road with free parking, lifeguards, a fishing pier, a boat ramp and the 1954 Jack West beach pavilion. North Jetty, at the south tip on Venice Inlet, is a local spot for fishing and surfing.

Hurricanes Helene and Milton hit Casey Key hard in 2024. When you look at a home here, ask for the elevation certificate and flood zone, price flood and wind insurance before you write an offer, and check the permit history for any work done after the storms. Downtown Venice is a short drive south, and Sarasota is about 17 miles north on US 41.

Parks and outdoors near Casey Key

  • Nokomis Beach Park

    Gulf beach park

    A county beach park with lifeguards, a fishing pier, a boat ramp, a kayak launch, a playground, and sand volleyball.

    100 Casey Key Road, Nokomis, FL 34275

    Show on map: Nokomis Beach Park
  • North Jetty Park

    Gulf beach park

    A county beach park with lifeguards, a picnic pavilion, grills, a playground, and a concession.

    1000 S. Casey Key Road, Nokomis, FL 34275

    Show on map: North Jetty Park

Looking for a home close to the parks and the water in Casey Key? I'll show you where to look. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Weather, month by month

Average high and low in °F, and rain in inches, for each month.

Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ)

  1. Janhigh 72.5°low 52.3°2.8 in
  2. Febhigh 74.9°low 54.6°1.9 in
  3. Marhigh 78.2°low 58.1°2.9 in
  4. Aprhigh 82.5°low 62.7°2.5 in
  5. Mayhigh 87.5°low 68.2°2.6 in
  6. Junhigh 90.0°low 73.6°7.1 in
  7. Julhigh 91.1°low 75.2°7.4 in
  8. Aughigh 91.5°low 75.3°9.1 in
  9. Sephigh 90.2°low 74.1°6.0 in
  10. Octhigh 86.3°low 68.3°2.8 in
  11. Novhigh 80.0°low 60.1°1.8 in
  12. Dechigh 75.2°low 55.2°2.3 in

Atlantic hurricane season runs June 1 to November 30 (NOAA National Hurricane Center, https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/climo/); June through September is the rainy season, with most afternoons bringing a short thunderstorm.

NOAA climate normals, 1991 to 2020, Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ). Source: NOAA NCEI U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020, station Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/land-based-station/us-climate-normals), as reproduced in the Sarasota, Florida climate table (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarasota,_Florida); read 2026-10-04.

What to know before you buy in Casey Key

  • I will confirm the HOA and any CDD fees, what they cover, and whether a transfer fee applies at closing.
  • I will check the flood zone and elevation of the home, and we will get a flood insurance quote before your inspection period ends.
  • If you might rent the home out someday, I will review the rental and lease rules with you.
  • We will look at drive times to work, to SRQ, and to the beaches at the hours you would actually travel.

Buying in Casey Key? We can go through everything before you make an offer. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Casey Key FAQ

How do you get onto Casey Key?

Two bridges cross the Intracoastal Waterway to the island. At the north end, Blackburn Point Road runs from US 41 in Osprey over the Blackburn Point Bridge, a one-lane steel truss swing bridge that opened in 1926 and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. To the south, Albee Road runs from US 41 over the Albee Road Bridge, a two-lane bascule drawbridge built in 1963. Both bridges open for boat traffic, so allow a few extra minutes at times.

What kinds of homes are on Casey Key?

Almost all are single-family homes. You will find Gulf-front houses with their own stretch of beach, bayfront homes with docks on Blackburn Bay and the Intracoastal, and a few wide lots that run from the Gulf to the bay. Homes range from houses built in 1947 to new houses under construction now, with a median of about 2,900 square feet. A handful of condos and vacant lots also come up for sale.

Can I keep a boat at a Casey Key home?

Yes, on the bay side. Many bayfront homes have private docks on Blackburn Bay or the Intracoastal Waterway, and some listings describe deep-water frontage. The Blackburn Point Bridge has about 9 feet of clearance when closed and swings open for taller boats. Check water depth at the dock, lift capacity and dock permits for the home you are considering.

Where are the public beaches on Casey Key?

Nokomis Beach, at 100 Casey Key Road off Albee Road, is Sarasota County's oldest public beach. It has free parking, lifeguards year-round, restrooms, a fishing pier, a boat ramp, a kayak launch and the 1954 beach pavilion by Jack West of the Sarasota School of Architecture, now on the National Register. North Jetty, a separate park at the south tip on Venice Inlet, is known for fishing from the rocks and for surfing when the Gulf is rough. Dogs are not allowed on Nokomis Beach.

What should I check about storms and flooding on Casey Key?

Casey Key took heavy damage from Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024. For any home, ask for the elevation certificate and flood zone, get flood and wind insurance quotes early, and review the permit history for repairs or rebuilding since 2024.

Is Casey Key part of Nokomis or Osprey?

Neither town governs it. Casey Key is in unincorporated Sarasota County and is not part of any census-designated place. Homes carry Nokomis (34275) or Osprey (34229) mailing addresses, and county services and taxes apply.

Have a question about Casey Key that isn't answered here? Please let me know. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

For sale now

Casey Key homes for sale

I can send you new Casey Key listings as soon as they come on the market, often before they reach the major portals. Ask Janelle

Nearby

Communities near Casey Key in its price range

All of Islands & Beaches
  • Aerial view of St. Armands Circle and its shops, with Lido Key and the Gulf of Mexico beyond

    Islands & Beaches

    St. Armands

    Waterfront

    Median asking price $3.90M

  • Sarasota Bay and the John Ringling Causeway seen from Bird Key

    Islands & Beaches

    Bird Key

    Waterfront, New construction

    Median asking price $6.99M

Last counted October 28, 2026

The market on October 28, 2026

Homes for sale
15
Median asking price
$4.80M

Every quarter

Prices in Casey Key

These are the homes sold in Casey Key from July to September 2026, by closing date.

Homes sold
1

With fewer than 3 sales in the quarter, I do not show a median.

SalesJuly to September 2026July to September 2025
Homes sold14
Median sale priceFewer than 3 sales$3,825,000
Median price per sq ftFewer than 3 sales$1,350

On October 28, 2026, 15 homes were for sale in Casey Key, at a median list price of $4.80M and a median of $1,211 per square foot.

These figures are closed sales of homes (no land) in Stellar MLS, in the places this page's home search covers. Medians and the lowest and highest sales require at least 3 homes.

I update these figures every quarter from MLS sales. This is the July to September 2026 quarter, and the next update is in January 2027.

Keep reading

Guides from Janelle

All guides

New listings

Get new Casey Key listings first.

New Casey Key listings often sell within days. Let me know your preferred criteria. I'll make sure you know about new listings instantly, and we can explore off market opportunities too. If you would rather talk, call or text me at (813) 394-3313.

Along with your message, this site shares how you first found it: the first page you opened here and the website that referred you. How this works

Reviews

What clients say

Read all 39 reviews

5.0 from 41 reviews on Google, Zillow, Realtor.com, RateMyAgent, and HomeLight

  • Janelle is fantastic. We recently were able to sell our home in one week at 1% over asking price. I believe that the professional photos and staging coupled with Janelle helping us price competitively led to this success. We closed in one month and are so very grateful for Janelle and her help with the sale of our property.

    Bob Conner Google, October 7, 2026

    Sold a home

  • I highly recommend Janelle Mertins She is extremely knowledgeable, honest, and incredibly helpful throughout the entire process. She is also very responsive and even made herself available after hours when needed. After working with several agents in the Sarasota area, Janelle truly stood out. Her professionalism and dedication made all the difference.

    Pools by Jeff Google, April 7, 2026

  • Janelle did a great job selling our house. We have worked with 4 realtors over the past 19 years in FL, and she was by far the best. She is very knowledgeable about the real estate market, and was great at communicating with us throughout the sales process. Her responses to our emails and texts were very detailed and timely. She was also very proactive with recommendations on how to get our house ready for sale, and she went above and beyond to make sure our house was sparkling clean and staged appropriately to make sure our house stood out compared to others. The video she created for our...

    Seller RateMyAgent, July 20, 2025

    Sold a home in Bradenton

Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte

Areas served

See all 431 communities
Janelle Mertins

Janelle Mertins · Compass

Would you like to see Casey Key in person?

Call or text me directly whenever it suits you, or send me a note about the home, community, or move you have in mind.

With deep local knowledge and true builder insight, I make sure my clients are fully informed. I cater to a select group of discerning clients who value concierge-level service. Identifying the most suitable neighborhoods, builders, and properties, and negotiating the best terms, requires extensive experience.

I specialize in custom luxury and new construction, because that was my professional background prior to general real estate. However, I treat clients with the same level of care whether they are purchasing an investment condo or a legacy estate.

My sales and marketing record for some of the region's top builders was rewarding, but nothing compares to the satisfaction of helping individual clients achieve their goals.

17 years of real estate experience · Top 1% of agents in Sarasota & Manatee County and top 1.5% in the USA (RealTrends Verified)

Contact Janelle

Janelle Mertins

Realtor, Compass

Contact Janelle Mertins.

Call, text, email, or ask here