Anna Maria Island real estate market report, October 2026

Updated by Janelle Mertins, Compass

As of October 14, 2026, 111 homes were for sale across 15 Anna Maria Island communities on this site, with median asking prices from $621,950 in Seaside Gardens to $6,950,000 in Bimini Bay Estates. In October 2026, 17 homes closed at a median price of $1,137,500 (Stellar MLS).

Janelle's take

In October, Anna Maria Island has 111 homes for sale across 15 communities. Median asking prices run from $621,950 in Seaside Gardens to $6,950,000 in Bimini Bay Estates. I would suggest you decide how you plan to use the home, as a residence or a getaway, before you begin touring, and I will guide you from there.

Janelle Mertins,

Anna Maria Island by the numbers

Anna Maria Island, October 2026
MeasureValueSource and how it is counted
Homes for sale111This site's home search (Stellar MLS through Showcase IDX), October 14, 2026. Across the 15 Anna Maria Island communities below that have a page on this site; homes elsewhere in Anna Maria Island are not counted.
Median asking price, whole area$1,794,500This site's home search (Stellar MLS through Showcase IDX), November 10, 2026. The middle asking price of all 244 homes for sale in Anna Maria Island: half ask more, half ask less.
Under contract (pending)19Stellar MLS, homes, condos, townhomes and villas sold or under contract with an Anna Maria, Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach address, November 8, 2026. Homes under contract (pending) in Stellar MLS on the day it was read.
Closed sales17Stellar MLS, homes, condos, townhomes and villas sold or under contract with an Anna Maria, Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach address, October 2026, November 8, 2026. Sales that closed in the month.
Median sold price$1,137,500Stellar MLS, homes, condos, townhomes and villas sold or under contract with an Anna Maria, Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach address, October 2026, November 8, 2026. Half of the month's sales closed above this price, half below.
Median sold price per square foot$723 per sq ftStellar MLS, homes, condos, townhomes and villas sold or under contract with an Anna Maria, Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach address, October 2026, November 8, 2026. Living area under air, as the MLS records it.
Median days on market82 daysStellar MLS, homes, condos, townhomes and villas sold or under contract with an Anna Maria, Holmes Beach or Bradenton Beach address, October 2026, November 8, 2026. Days from listing to contract for the month's closed sales.

Homes for sale by community

My community pages in Anna Maria Island, with homes for sale and the median asking price, as of October 13, 2026.
CommunityHomes for saleMedian asking price
Ilexhurst23$2,850,000
Anna Maria Beach19$2,849,500
Bay Palms12$1,622,500
Shore Acres11$3,295,000
Cortez Beach6$4,722,500
Luana Isles6$1,810,000
Seaside Gardens6$621,950
Sportsman's Harbor6$3,100,000
Bimini Bay Estates5$6,950,000
Key Royale4$2,837,500
Wells Bay Harbor4$3,225,000
Casanas3$1,450,000
Lake La Vista3$2,985,000
Anna Maria Island Club2
North Point Harbour1

Sources

Janelle Mertins is a licensed Florida real estate agent (license SL3288209) with Compass. This page is information, not an appraisal, a loan offer, or legal or tax advice.

Janelle Mertins

Janelle Mertins · Compass

Buying or selling in Anna Maria Island? Talk to Janelle

Call or text me directly whenever it suits you, or send me a note about the home, community, or move you have in mind.

I started in corporate new home sales at a Fortune 500 builder, then sold new luxury homes for Arthur Rutenberg Homes, Johnson Homes, London Bay Homes, and David Weekley Homes. I also worked onsite at The Lake Club, The Concession, and The Founders Club. I know how builders price, how their contracts and allowances work, and where a new or custom home can go over budget, and I put all of it to work for you.

My consistency is what sets me apart. My listings sell for about 97% of their list price, and 99% of the homes I list sell. I bring the same care to waterfront homes, homes west of the Trail, and the islands, where every lot, seawall, and flood zone is different. Whether you are buying, building, or selling a luxury home here, I will be your advocate from our first conversation through closing.

Contact Janelle

Janelle Mertins

Realtor, Compass

Contact Janelle Mertins

Call, text, email, or ask here