
Sell with Janelle
What is your home worth today?
I have sold 200+ homes, $160M+ in all. In a private listing presentation, I'll show you what yours could bring.

What happens in a listing presentation?
We sit down together, and I share my pricing for your home, built on the sales and the competition that truly matter. We shape a strategy for when to list, I walk you through how your home will be marketed, and I give you candid answers about what you could net.
There is no obligation. Request a listing presentation, and I will reach out to find a convenient time.
Informed. Industrious. Innovative!
Work with a Luxury Market Professional
I would be honored to be the advocate on your side.
Informed.
With years of experience as a top producer for ultra-luxury custom builders, Janelle possesses unparalleled insider knowledge. She thoroughly explains construction, development, and market positioning, helping her valued clients make informed choices.
Industrious.
Janelle helps one client at a time with personalized attention and works diligently to meet their goals. She has set many sales records in prestigious neighborhoods. She presents her buying clients with on-market and off-market homes. With compassion, unwavering efficiency and integrity, she consistently delivers remarkable results.
Innovative!
Janelle believes her clients deserve the very best marketing technology. She is frequently acknowledged for selling distinctive, custom luxury homes that previously faced challenges in the market. She helps sellers achieve top results with innovative marketing strategies.
Your listing presentation
What I bring to your listing presentation
Let's sit down together before you decide anything. I prepare specifically for your home, and you will leave with a clear picture, whether or not you choose to list with me.
What your home should bring
I will share my pricing for your home, built on the sales and the competition that truly matter rather than a figure per square foot.
When to list
We will shape a strategy around your goals and your timeline, so your home reaches the market at the right moment.
How it will be marketed
I will walk you through my plan for your home: luxury media, print, my website, and the agents I work with.
What you could net
You will receive candid answers about what is realistic and what could be achievable.
Timing and strategy
The right time to sell, and the playbook to get there
Many agents put a home on the market as soon as the listing agreement is signed. Listing at the wrong time can cost you money: buyers pay the most attention in a home's first weeks on the market, and those weeks should come when your home and the market are both ready. I build the strategy with you first, so you have the playbook in hand before the sign goes up.
What is realistic, and what is achievable
I am transparent about the numbers. I will tell you what is realistic, what could be achievable, and the one thing most sellers would rather not hear: whether their own number holds up. My goal is the greatest net for you, meaning the money you keep after the sale, not the biggest number on a sign.
No surprises
We will discuss any price change, and any change to the plan, ahead of time. Nothing happens to your listing without your knowing about it first.
Pricing
Why price per square foot misleads in the luxury market
Price per square foot is a quick way to compare homes that are alike. In the luxury market, almost no two homes are alike, and the figure can cost a seller in either direction.
The lot and the view
Water, golf-course, and preserve views, privacy, and an oversized lot add value that square feet do not measure.
How the home was built
A custom home with impact glass, a concrete-block structure, and designer finishes is a different product from a production home of the same size.
Size works against the figure
Price per square foot falls as homes get larger, so a large home measured against smaller sales looks overpriced, and a small one looks like a bargain.
I price a luxury home the way buyers and appraisers judge it, and I'll walk you through your home's price in person.
Concierge service
A true concierge, with facts instead of opinions
I manage your sale the way a fine concierge manages a stay: every detail is known and taken care of before you have to ask. I gather the facts about your home and your community, coordinate the people who prepare it, and keep you informed from the first walk-through to the closing table.
Candor and transparency are what set my service apart. I give you facts rather than opinions, and I will never tell you only what you want to hear in order to win your listing. My price comes from closed sales, the homes you will compete with this month, and what buyers in your price range are paying now, and I show you the numbers behind it. If an update will not pay for itself, I will tell you so. If a price is too high to bring in buyers during the first weeks, I will tell you that as well, before the market says it for you.
New construction experience
I learned this business inside new construction
Many homes in Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte counties sell within a short drive of a builder that is still selling new ones. Your buyer will compare your home with the model down the road, along with its incentives and its price list. Because I sold for builders, I know how they price, which options buyers will pay for, and what a new home really costs once lot premiums, upgrades, and landscaping are added.
That knowledge is how I position a resale home to win: there is no wait to build, the landscaping has grown in, the window treatments and pool are already done, and the upgrades are ones a buyer would otherwise pay the builder for. With a custom home, I can explain to buyers exactly how it was built, from the structure and the windows to the finishes, so the price makes sense to them and to their appraiser.
Marketing
Marketing and technology built for a luxury home
See for yourself
Look through my website first
Before you choose an agent, take a look around my website. It is built to inform buyers and sellers, with dated market snapshots, a builder directory, and guides to living here, and it is where your home will be marketed.
My record, verified
A record that speaks for itself
Janelle's record
- #31in Sarasota by sales volume
- 168MLS sales since 2015
- 5.0from 41 reviews
Ranking: RealTrends Verified, 2025 sales data, my RealTrends profile. MLS sales: my Past Success page. Reviews: every review.
How I secure the highest price the market will pay
Priced on facts
I price your home so that serious buyers arrive in the first weeks, when interest is highest.
Presented as luxury
Your home is prepared, staged, and photographed as the fine home it is.
Seen beyond the neighborhood
My marketing reaches relocating buyers and the agents who bring them.
Protected at the table
I negotiate to hold your price through the inspection and the appraisal.
A strong sale also helps the whole street, because it becomes the sale the next appraiser compares with.
Choosing an agent
Questions to ask before you choose an agent
The agent you hire shapes the price, the marketing, and the negotiation, so ask every agent you interview these questions:
- How long have you been selling real estate full time, and what did you do before?
- Have you sold luxury, custom, or new-construction homes like mine?
- How will you price my home, and what will you show me to support that price?
- When should I list, and why then?
- Exactly how will you market my home, online and in print?
- What do you expect I will net, and what is realistic?
"I already have a buyer for your home"
Some agents will say anything to get a listing, and a waiting buyer is a common promise. Ask for specifics: has that buyer seen your home, are they approved to buy at your price, and will they put it in writing? A promise is not a plan.
Living in the community is not a track record
Knowing the clubhouse is not the same as knowing how to price, prepare, and market a luxury home. An agent without luxury or new-construction experience may price to the last sale, accept the first offer, or cut the price for a quick result. In a small community, each of those sales becomes the next comparable, so one fire sale lowers what every home around it is worth.
Why a discount agent can cost you more
On a $2,000,000 home:
$20,000 saved by a fee one point lower$60,000 lost to a price 3 percent lower
Discount models usually depend on volume, which means more listings for each agent and less spent on each home. Compare what you would net, not only what you would pay. Commissions are not set by law and are always negotiable.
Sources, checked October 3, 2026: RealTrends Verified: Janelle Mertins; Compass: Janelle Mertins. Rankings are RealTrends Verified's, on 2025 sales data.
In Janelle's words
Sell your Sarasota, Manatee or Charlotte County home
Selling a home on Florida's Gulf Coast is about more than listing it. It's about positioning your property to reach the right buyers at the right price. With deep roots in the Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte County markets and years of experience in both resale and new construction, I bring an insider's perspective to every listing, along with a strategy built around your specific goals and timeline.
Before your home ever hits the market, I start with a detailed comparative market analysis to price it accurately from day one, because homes priced right from the start typically sell faster and for more. From there, we'll talk through any updates, staging, or repairs that will offer the best return, so your home shows at its absolute best to every buyer who walks through the door.
Once we're ready to list, I handle the details that make a difference: professional photography, compelling property descriptions, targeted marketing to qualified buyers and agents, and proactive outreach across my network of local and relocating clients. Throughout the process, I'll keep you informed every step of the way, from showings and offers to negotiations and closing, so nothing catches you off guard.
It might be a waterfront retreat, a home in a gated golf community, or a custom-built property. My goal doesn't change: the best result for you, with as little stress as possible. When you're ready, we can talk through your options, and I'll give you an honest read on where your home stands right now.
Janelle Mertins
Privacy
I believe in the value of privacy and offer each of my clients the assurance that their transaction will be managed professionally and privately, as they wish.

Request your listing presentation
Tell me a little about your home. I will reach out to find a convenient time and prepare my pricing, timing, and marketing plan for it. There is no obligation.
Military families
Active duty, Reserve, and Guard families
Mine is a military family: my husband, Enrique, serves in the U.S. Army Reserve, and my brother-in-law, recently off active duty as an Air Force pilot, now flies for the Air National Guard. Moving here on PCS orders, drilling here with a Reserve or Guard unit, or leaving on new orders? I will work with your family to secure the best possible pricing, and sellers receive a flexible, personalized marketing plan built around their orders and schedule.
For sale now
Active listings
For sale
The Founders Club listings
See every home for sale in The Founders Club
Monterey at Lakewood Ranch listings
See every home for sale in Monterey at Lakewood Ranch
I can send you new listings as soon as they come on the market, often before they reach the major portals. Ask Janelle
Homes I have sold for my clients
-
Sold$3,125,000
8847 Colonels Court
Represented the seller
-
Sold$1,525,000
5822 Title Row Drive
Represented the seller
-
Sold$1,225,000
5707 Inspiration Terrace
Represented the seller

Janelle Mertins · Compass
Thinking about selling? Let's talk
Call or text me directly whenever it suits you, or send me a note about the home, community, or move you have in mind.
I started in corporate new home sales at a Fortune 500 builder, then sold new luxury homes for Arthur Rutenberg Homes, Johnson Homes, London Bay Homes, and David Weekley Homes. I also worked onsite at The Lake Club, The Concession, and The Founders Club. I know how builders price, how their contracts and allowances work, and where a new or custom home can go over budget, and I put all of it to work for you.
My consistency is what sets me apart. My listings sell for about 97% of their list price, and 99% of the homes I list sell. I bring the same care to waterfront homes, homes west of the Trail, and the islands, where every lot, seawall, and flood zone is different. Whether you are buying, building, or selling a luxury home here, I will be your advocate from our first conversation through closing.
















