Siesta Key real estate market report, October 2026
Updated by Janelle Mertins, Compass
As of October 14, 2026, 101 homes were for sale across 24 Siesta Key communities on this site, with median asking prices from $600,000 in Whispering Sands to $7,100,000 in Sanderling Club.
Janelle's take
This October, Siesta Key offers 101 homes for sale across 24 communities. Median asking prices run from $600,000 in Whispering Sands to $7,100,000 in Sanderling Club, which is a wide range for a small island. If you are buying, I would decide how close to the beach you need to be, because that choice shapes the price more than anything else.
Siesta Key by the numbers
| Measure | Value | Source and how it is counted |
|---|---|---|
| Homes for sale | 101 | Her site's home search (Stellar MLS through Showcase IDX), October 14, 2026. Across the 24 Siesta Key communities below that have a page on this site; homes elsewhere in Siesta Key are not counted. |
| Median asking price, whole area | Not available | Not available for the whole area; each community's median asking price is in the table below. |
| Under contract (pending) | Not available | Not available yet: Janelle adds this from Stellar MLS each month. |
| Closed sales | Not available | Not available yet: Janelle adds this from Stellar MLS each month. |
| Median sold price | Not available | Not available yet: Janelle adds this from Stellar MLS each month. |
| Median sold price per square foot | Not available | Not available yet: Janelle adds this from Stellar MLS each month. |
| Median days on market | Not available | Not available yet: Janelle adds this from Stellar MLS each month. |
Homes for sale by community
| Community | Homes for sale | Median asking price |
|---|---|---|
| Bay Island | 10 | $3,950,000 |
| Bay Isle and Higel Avenue | 10 | $6,097,500 |
| Siesta Isles | 7 | $2,300,000 |
| Whispering Sands | 7 | $600,000 |
| Sanderling Club | 6 | $7,100,000 |
| Casarina | 5 | $1,400,000 |
| Gulf and Bay Club | 5 | $1,199,000 |
| Harbor Towers Yacht and Racquet Club | 5 | $634,900 |
| Excelsior | 4 | $712,000 |
| Island House | 4 | $1,497,500 |
| Island Reef | 4 | $602,450 |
| Sunset Beach | 4 | $5,100,000 |
| Crystal Sands | 3 | $1,275,000 |
| Dolphin Bay | 3 | $1,500,000 |
| Horizons West | 3 | $1,124,000 |
| Peppertree Bay | 3 | $670,000 |
| Sarasota Surf and Racquet Club | 3 | $1,250,000 |
| Siesta Gulf View | 3 | $1,495,000 |
| Ten35 Seaside | 3 | $2,550,000 |
| Hidden Harbor | 2 | Not available |
| Mira Mar and Siesta Point | 2 | Not available |
| Palm Bay Club | 2 | Not available |
| Siesta Breakers | 2 | Not available |
| Point of Rocks | 1 | Not available |
Sources
Janelle Mertins is a licensed Florida real estate agent (license SL3288209) with Compass. This page is information, not an appraisal, a loan offer, or legal or tax advice.
Janelle Mertins · Compass
Buying or selling in Siesta Key? Talk to Janelle
Call or text me directly whenever it suits you, or send me a note about the home, community, or move you have in mind.