A red lifeguard stand with an American flag above the white quartz sand of Siesta Beach
A lifeguard stand on Siesta Beach, Siesta Key (Mickey Luigi Logitmark, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons)

Siesta Key · Waterfront · Condo

Island Reef in Siesta Key

This Gulf-to-bay condominium on Midnight Pass Road on south Siesta Key, near Turtle Beach, was built from 1975 to 1981 and offers two pools, boat docks and a fishing pier.

At a glance

Island Reef at a glance

Island Reef is a community on Midnight Pass Road on the south end of Siesta Key, 2 minutes from Turtle Beach Park and Ophelia's on the Bay.

Median asking price
$602K
Airport
SRQ, 29 min drive
Lifestyle
Waterfront, Condo
Janelle Mertins

Janelle Mertins · Compass

Let Janelle's experience work for you

With a deep firsthand understanding of the luxury and new construction market and as one of the top agents in Lakewood Ranch and East Sarasota, Janelle is uniquely qualified to represent you. Dedicated to helping clients understand construction and the local building industry, she routinely makes the buying process seamless for her new construction buyers. Let her be your advocate from start to finish and bring clarity to your choices, the market, and the process. Her background in new and luxury homes makes her the perfect choice for the most discerning clients. Text for the fastest response and to book your appointment or complimentary consultation.

The area

Living in Island Reef

Overview of Island Reef

Address
Midnight Pass Road, south Siesta Key
HOA
Depends on the unit; I confirm it for the address
School district
Sarasota County
Turtle Beach
2 min drive

About Island Reef

  • Turtle Beach Park and Ophelia's on the Bay are about 2 minutes away.
  • The free Route 77 Siesta Islander trolley runs along Midnight Pass Road.
  • Siesta Key Village is about 13 minutes north.

Island Reef is a Gulf-to-bay condominium on Midnight Pass Road on the south end of Siesta Key, near Turtle Beach. Its grounds stretch from a Gulf beach back to the bay, and the free Siesta Breeze trolley stops right outside.

The complex was built between 1975 and 1981. Condos sold in the last two years were about 1,290 to 1,490 square feet, most with enclosed lanais and covered parking, and sold for about $550,000 to $700,000.

Amenities include two heated pools, one on the Gulf and one on the bay, a fitness center, clubhouse, library and billiards room, tennis and pickleball courts, shuffleboard, boat docks, a fishing pier and a kayak launch. I can get you the current Island Reef association documents, including the rental, pet and renovation rules, on any unit before you write an offer.

Schools near Island Reef

School assignments depend on the address, so please confirm them with the school district. Florida school grades from the Department of Education (opens in a new tab)

Comparing school zones in Island Reef? I'll match them to the homes for sale. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Restaurants near Island Reef

Would you like to live near the best of Island Reef? I know which streets put it right at your door. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Things to do near Island Reef

Curious what life in Island Reef is like from week to week? I can tell you more and show you around. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Parks and outdoors near Island Reef

Looking for a home close to the parks and the water in Island Reef? I'll show you where to look. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Shopping near Island Reef

Would you like everyday errands close at hand in Island Reef? I can point you to the right neighborhoods. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Health care near Island Reef

Do you need to be near medical care in Island Reef? I'll keep that in mind when I choose homes to show you. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Getting around near Island Reef

Commuting from Island Reef? Ask me what the drive is like from each neighborhood. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Weather, month by month

Average high and low in °F, and rain in inches, for each month.

Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ)

  1. Janhigh 72.5°low 52.3°2.8 in
  2. Febhigh 74.9°low 54.6°1.9 in
  3. Marhigh 78.2°low 58.1°2.9 in
  4. Aprhigh 82.5°low 62.7°2.5 in
  5. Mayhigh 87.5°low 68.2°2.6 in
  6. Junhigh 90.0°low 73.6°7.1 in
  7. Julhigh 91.1°low 75.2°7.4 in
  8. Aughigh 91.5°low 75.3°9.1 in
  9. Sephigh 90.2°low 74.1°6.0 in
  10. Octhigh 86.3°low 68.3°2.8 in
  11. Novhigh 80.0°low 60.1°1.8 in
  12. Dechigh 75.2°low 55.2°2.3 in

Atlantic hurricane season runs June 1 to November 30 (NOAA National Hurricane Center, https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/climo/); June through September is the rainy season, with most afternoons bringing a short thunderstorm.

NOAA climate normals, 1991 to 2020, Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ). Source: NOAA NCEI U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020, station Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/land-based-station/us-climate-normals), as reproduced in the Sarasota, Florida climate table (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarasota,_Florida); read 2026-10-04.

What to know before you buy in Island Reef

  • I will confirm the HOA and any CDD fees, what they cover, and whether a transfer fee applies at closing.
  • I will check the flood zone and elevation of the home, and we will get a flood insurance quote before your inspection period ends.
  • If you might rent the home out someday, I will review the rental and lease rules with you.
  • We will look at drive times to work, to SRQ, and to the beaches at the hours you would actually travel.

Buying in Island Reef? We can go through everything before you make an offer. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Island Reef FAQ

Where is Island Reef?

Island Reef is on Midnight Pass Road on the south end of Siesta Key, near Turtle Beach. It runs from the Gulf to the bay, and the free Siesta Breeze trolley stops right outside the property.

What amenities does Island Reef have?

Island Reef has two heated pools, one on the Gulf and one on the bay, a fitness center, clubhouse, library and billiards room, tennis and pickleball courts, shuffleboard, boat docks, a fishing pier, a kayak launch and its own Gulf beach.

What kinds of condos are at Island Reef?

The buildings went up between 1975 and 1981, in sections known as Island Reef I and Island Reef II. Units sold in the last two years were about 1,290 to 1,490 square feet, most with enclosed lanais and covered parking.

What do condos at Island Reef sell for?

Condos sold for about $550,000 to $700,000 in the last two years, most around $600,000.

Have a question about Island Reef that isn't answered here? Please let me know. Email me or call me at (813) 394-3313.

Nearby

Communities near Island Reef in its price range

All of Siesta Key

Last counted October 13, 2026

The market on October 13, 2026

Homes for sale
4
Median asking price
$602K

Estimate the monthly cost of a home here

Every quarter

Prices in Island Reef

These are the homes sold in Island Reef from July to September 2026, by closing date.

Homes sold
1

With fewer than 3 sales in the quarter, I do not show a median.

On October 13, 2026, 4 homes were for sale in Island Reef, at a median list price of $602K and a median of $456 per square foot.

These figures are closed sales of homes (no land) in Stellar MLS, in the places this page's home search covers. Medians and the lowest and highest sales require at least 3 homes.

I update these figures every quarter from MLS sales. This is the July to September 2026 quarter, and the next update is in January 2027.

Keep reading

Guides from Janelle

All guides

New listings

Get new Island Reef listings first

New Island Reef listings often sell within days. Tell me what you're looking for, and I'll send you new and coming-soon homes as soon as they come on the market, often before they reach the major portals. If you would rather talk, call or text me at (813) 394-3313.

Along with your message, this site shares how you first found it: the first page you opened here and the website that referred you. How this works

Reviews

What clients say

Read all 39 reviews

5.0 from 41 reviews on Google, Zillow, Realtor.com, RateMyAgent, and HomeLight

  • Janelle is fantastic. We recently were able to sell our home in one week at 1% over asking price. I believe that the professional photos and staging coupled with Janelle helping us price competitively led to this success. We closed in one month and are so very grateful for Janelle and her help with the sale of our property.

    Bob Conner Google, October 7, 2026

    Sold a home

  • I highly recommend Janelle Mertins She is extremely knowledgeable, honest, and incredibly helpful throughout the entire process. She is also very responsive and even made herself available after hours when needed. After working with several agents in the Sarasota area, Janelle truly stood out. Her professionalism and dedication made all the difference.

    Pools by Jeff Google, April 7, 2026

  • Janelle did a great job selling our house. We have worked with 4 realtors over the past 19 years in FL, and she was by far the best. She is very knowledgeable about the real estate market, and was great at communicating with us throughout the sales process. Her responses to our emails and texts were very detailed and timely. She was also very proactive with recommendations on how to get our house ready for sale, and she went above and beyond to make sure our house was sparkling clean and staged appropriately to make sure our house stood out compared to others. The video she created for our...

    Seller RateMyAgent, July 20, 2025

    Sold a home in Bradenton

Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte

Areas served

See all 431 communities
Janelle Mertins

Janelle Mertins · Compass

Would you like to see Island Reef in person?

Call or text me directly whenever it suits you, or send me a note about the home, community, or move you have in mind.

I started in corporate new home sales at a Fortune 500 builder, then sold new luxury homes for Arthur Rutenberg Homes, Johnson Homes, London Bay Homes, and David Weekley Homes. I also worked onsite at The Lake Club, The Concession, and The Founders Club. I know how builders price, how their contracts and allowances work, and where a new or custom home can go over budget, and I put all of it to work for you.

My consistency is what sets me apart. My listings sell for about 97% of their list price, and 99% of the homes I list sell. I bring the same care to waterfront homes, homes west of the Trail, and the islands, where every lot, seawall, and flood zone is different. Whether you are buying, building, or selling a luxury home here, I will be your advocate from our first conversation through closing.

Contact Janelle

Janelle Mertins

Realtor, Compass

Contact Janelle Mertins

Call, text, email, or ask here