Places covered Monterey at Lakewood Ranch Wild Blue at Waterside Shellstone at Waterside Waterbury Park Lakewood Ranch

Monterey at Lakewood Ranch is the gated Toll Brothers choice in the $700,000s to $1.6 million builder range, and its neighbors on price are Wild Blue and Shellstone at Waterside, Waterbury Park, The Lake Club, and, next, Taylor Morrison’s planned Esplanade at Cammaray.
Monterey’s Toll Brothers base prices start at $738,995 for 2,517 square feet, while the others offer a finished club, a small private enclave, or a custom builder. On October 12, the homes for sale in Monterey had a median asking price of $1.49 million.
If you’re weighing two or three of these, call or text me at (813) 394-3313 and I’ll walk the models with you and line up the prices, dues, and quick move-ins side by side.
Monterey and its price-range neighbors side by side
| Community | Builders and published prices, October 31 | Median asking price on my pages |
|---|---|---|
| Monterey at Lakewood Ranch | Toll Brothers, base prices from $738,995 to $1,614,995 | $1.49M (4 homes, October 12) |
| Wild Blue at Waterside | Stock Luxury Homes from $1M, Lee Wetherington from $1.5M, AR Homes and John Cannon from $2M, Anchor from $3M | $3.04M (11 homes, October 13) |
| Shellstone at Waterside | Homes by Towne 65-foot homesite series from $901,900 to $1,101,900, Lee Wetherington custom homes from $2M | $1.87M (5 homes, October 13) |
| Waterbury Park | Neal Signature Homes from $1.3M | 2 homes pending at $1,830,990 and $1,997,990 (October 14) |
| The Lake Club | Stock, now mostly resales | $2.13M (11 homes, October 12) |
| Esplanade at Cammaray | Taylor Morrison, coming soon, prices not yet published | No homes yet |
| Community | Homes and sizes | County, ZIP, and gate |
|---|---|---|
| Monterey at Lakewood Ranch | Single-family, 2,517 to 5,779 sq ft, 3- or 4-car garages | Sarasota County, 34240, gated |
| Wild Blue at Waterside | 505 single-family homes, about 2,400 to 4,575 sq ft | Sarasota County, 34240, no gate listed |
| Shellstone at Waterside | 682 paired villas and single-family homes; Towne plans 1,692 to 3,733 sq ft | Sarasota County, 34240, no gate listed |
| Waterbury Park | 21 single-family homes, 3,138 to 4,189 sq ft | Manatee County, 34202, gated |
| The Lake Club | Single-family luxury and custom estate homes | Manatee County, 34202, guard-gated |
| Esplanade at Cammaray | About 1,200 single-family homes, condos, and twin villas planned | Lakewood Ranch, gated as planned |
Monterey: Toll Brothers base prices from $738,995
Toll’s Ardenna collection starts at $738,995 for the Rossi, a one-story plan of 2,517 square feet, and Shearwater at $957,995, all with at least a 3-car garage. On October 31, Toll listed the four Egret plans from $1,299,995 to $1,614,995, while its summary still said “anticipated from the $1,900,000s,” so I get the current price sheet. Toll also had five quick move-in homes from $1,125,000 to $2,005,000, moving in January to March 2027.
The clubhouse and other amenities are still to come. Lakewood Ranch lists HOA dues at $352 to $373 a month, and I pull the current HOA, CDD, and tax figures for any home you’re serious about.
Wild Blue at Waterside: the club is ready, and the prices are higher.

Wild Blue is Stock Development’s 505-home Waterside village, on Monterey’s Sarasota County side. Lakewood Ranch lists a bar and restaurant and HOA dues of $800 to $900 a month, and Stock announced in August that its clubhouse opens this fall. On October 13 the 11 homes for sale had a median asking price of $3.04 million.
Shellstone at Waterside: Towne’s larger homes and Lee Wetherington

Shellstone, Wild Blue’s neighbor on Lake Merganser, has 682 homes across a wide range, so I compare only its top tiers with Monterey. Towne’s Islander is 2,675 square feet at $901,900, while Toll’s Ballast at Monterey is 3,291 square feet at $957,995. The Summit amenity center and the 13-acre Midway Park are already open, and Lakewood Ranch lists dues of $396 to $475 a month. On October 31, Towne had three 65-foot quick move-ins with pools from $1,299,900 to $1,479,900.
Waterbury Park: a 21-home gated enclave by Neal Signature Homes
Waterbury Park is 21 gated lakeside homes off The Masters Avenue east of Lorraine Road, built by Neal Signature Homes, with maintenance included. With 34202 addresses, schools and taxes follow Manatee County. On October 14, two homes were pending at $1,830,990 and $1,997,990.
The Lake Club: the established guard-gated club
The Lake Club has a 20,000-square-foot Grande Clubhouse, a spa, pools, and tennis, minutes from Main Street. I worked onsite there selling new homes. Stock’s website no longer listed it on October 31, so it’s mostly a resale market now, and on October 12 the 11 homes for sale had a median asking price of $2.13 million.
Esplanade at Cammaray: Taylor Morrison’s next gated community nearby
Taylor Morrison announced Esplanade at Cammaray in December 2025, with a resort pool and spa, a Culinary Center, a Wellness Center, and a Bahama Bar but no golf course. Sales are expected to start in early 2027. Prices aren’t published.
What each community offers
- Monterey for a large home, a 3-car garage, a gate, and Sarasota County schools from the $700,000s.
- Wild Blue for a higher budget and a full club with dining now.
- Shellstone for open amenities and a Towne or Lee Wetherington home near Monterey’s price.
- Waterbury Park for a small gated street with included maintenance.
- The Lake Club for an established guard-gated club and a finished resale.
If you lean toward Monterey, my Monterey market update covers its recent sales.
What I do for you at the builder’s sales center
The builder’s sales team works for the builder; I work for you. I walk the models with you, get in writing what the base price includes and what options cost, and compare builder incentives with an outside lender by monthly cost. I sold new luxury homes for Arthur Rutenberg Homes, Johnson Homes, London Bay Homes, and David Weekley Homes, so I know how builders price lots and options.
Toll Brothers says I have to register you at your first visit to Monterey, and Neal Signature Homes says I have to be with you at your first visit to Waterbury Park; both registrations last 90 days, and my guide on builder agent registration explains it.
When you’re ready to see Monterey or its neighbors, call or text me at (813) 394-3313, or send a note through my contact page with the communities and price range you have in mind. I’ll set up the model visits and pull the HOA and CDD amounts.
Get new listings first.
Let me know your preferred criteria. I’ll make sure you know about new listings instantly, and we can explore off market opportunities too.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Janelle Mertins is a licensed real estate agent with Compass.





